· 1 min read · UX, Design systems
Consistent icons are not enough

Icon Maker Studio wrote a nice piece on keeping icon sets consistent. One grid, one stroke width, and shapes adjusted by eye so they look equal. Making the thousandth icon look like it came from the same hand is hard (whether users care is another question).
Nielsen Norman Group tested a clock icon for browsing history. One test, but a good one. People knew it was a clock. Not one participant clicked it. Their advice: add a text label. A perfectly consistent set nobody can read still failed.
So ask if the thousandth icon belongs in the set. Then ask if anyone recognizes it.
Comments